The M20.3 flip moved ACPI namespace enumeration to the ring-3 acpi
service; the kernel now builds the namespace only for the \_S5 sleep
type. That left the kernel's AML-to-device helpers unreferenced.
Remove the dead cluster (wireAcpiDevices, mirrorDevices, applyHid,
setEisaHid, applyCrs, parseResourceTemplate, parseAddressSpace,
devicePresent, matchHostBridge, findPciNode, readAdr, isPciRootNode,
isPciRootHid, PciContext) and every AML-decoding helper it alone used
(eisaIdToStr, seg4, cstr, hexDigit, rd16, rd32, readN, readLE,
readIntObj, packageLength/PkgLen) plus their tests and the now-orphaned
acpi-ids import. The static-table path keeps checksumOk, fadt, readGas,
readCntRegister, and rd. Also tidies two stale comments.
The kernel no longer folds AML Device objects into the device tree — the
ring-3 acpi service is the sole builder of _HID device nodes. The kernel
keeps building the namespace only for the \_S5 sleep type, and still
seeds the static tables (MADT, HPET, MCFG, FADT) and the acpi-tables node.
The device manager matches ps2-bus from the service's _HID reports
(PNP0303 / PNP0F13, singleton-deduped) instead of boot-snapshot nodes;
its dead boot-snapshot ps2 arm is gone. The service registers every
device before reporting any, so a driver the manager spawns on the first
report already sees the full set — no keyboard-before-mouse race. The
acpi-ps2 scenario proves the whole chain: report -> spawn -> ps2-bus
finds the controller and attaches its keyboard, entirely in ring 3. The
ioport test moved to the acpi-tables I/O window, since the kernel-built
PS/2 node it used to scan for no longer exists. The retired
device-building functions in acpi.zig are dead but retained (a botched
mechanical deletion is worse mid-migration than a follow-up sweep, which
is flagged as a task). Suite 58/58.
AML method evaluation now runs in userspace touching real hardware: the
service builds an interpreter with a ring-3 Hal (port I/O routed through
its claimed acpi-tables node; a scratch page backs SystemMemory maps so a
stray OperationRegion degrades to zeros instead of faulting a process
that cannot map arbitrary physical memory). It walks the namespace and,
for each present _HID device that is not a PCI root, evaluates _CRS,
registers it under acpi-tables, and reports it with its EISA-decoded hid.
Containment for this needed the broker's irq check to become range-based
— an interrupt line is still indivisible, but a parent may own a range,
so the acpi-tables node's broad irq window contains its children's legacy
lines (a length-1 range is exactly the old equality, so single-irq
parents are unaffected). ChildAdded gained a hid field for firmware
string identity. Matching those reports to drivers stays off until M20.3,
so ps2-bus still comes up via the kernel path — no regression. The
acpi-report scenario proves the PS/2 keyboard (io 0x60/0x64 + IRQ) and
mouse (IRQ) are reported with their resources. Suite 57/57.
The AML module becomes a build module compiled into both the kernel (for
the \_S5 sleep state it still needs) and the new acpi service — one
source, two builds, no fork. The kernel publishes a single acpi-tables
node: the DSDT/SSDT blobs as memory resources, a broad io_port grant (the
honest trust boundary — firmware AML names whatever ports it chose, known
only after parsing), and the SCI for the M21 event track. The acpi
service claims the node, maps each blob through the ordinary mmio grant
(which preserves the sub-page offset onto the bytecode), and runs the
same parser the kernel does. It self-verifies its namespace Device count
against the kernel's — 34 = 34 — deterministically via an argv the
acpi-parse test passes, so no racing the shared serial buffer. Parse-only
touches no hardware; OperationRegion evaluation waits for _CRS/_STA in
M20.2. The manager spawns 'discovery' (the neutral ramdisk name) at
startup. Suite 56/56.
enumeratePci, addBars, pciConfigurationPtr, and the PciHeader struct are
deleted; the kernel seeds only the host bridge, and the ring-3 pci-bus
driver's reports are the sole source of PCI function nodes. The manager
matches PCI drivers from reported identity, deduped by registered device
id so a bus restart never double-spawns.
The flip did its job by exposing a latent SMP race: ring-3
device_register made the broker table concurrent for the first time, and
mmio_map read it lock-free — under load a torn resource length mapped
hpet's window wrong (its user fault) and underflowed r.len-1 into a
kernel integer-overflow panic. Fixed: the broker read in mmio_map (and
claim) runs under the big kernel lock, the arithmetic rejects
zero-length and wrapping windows cleanly, and pci-bus no longer registers
unimplemented size-0 BARs. driver-restart hammered 6x, suite 55/55.
Each function is registered under the bridge with the config-space slice
and BARs sized by the same all-ones probe the kernel uses — byte-for-byte
equal descriptors, so the idempotent register returns the kernel's
existing node ids during coexistence instead of duplicating the tree.
The bridge gained the 16-bit io_port aperture that functions' I/O BARs
need to pass containment. Reports carry the registered device_id, and
the pci-scan scenario drills a forced restart: kill the enumerator after
its reports, watch the respawn re-scan, and assert the broker's PCI node
count never grew. The usb-restart test trigger is pinned to the xHCI
reporter (pci-bus racing it to two reports used to steal the kill).
Harness hardening: failing cases preserve their serial logs; the heavy
scenarios run at 150s.
The host bridge now carries MMIO apertures derived from the boot memory
map's gaps below 4 GiB (largest three, sort-merged; a single after-the-
last-region hole dies on OVMF's flash at the top) plus one aperture above
the described space — so a user-space device_register of PCI functions
with BAR resources can pass containment. The discovery test asserts
every PCI memory resource lies inside a bridge window and names any
escapee. device_register is idempotent on exact (parent, class, identity,
resources) match — a restarted registering bus cannot duplicate its
children; proven directly against the broker in the bus test.
ChildAdded gains device_id so a report can carry the registered kernel
id a matched driver needs as its assignment.
Turn acpi-ids.zig's flat name table into a HardwareId enum modeled on
ps2-library's Port: one entry() switch holds the registry (variant ->
_HID string + human-readable name), with hid(), description(), and
fromHid() methods. The free description(hid) lookup the kernel's
device-tree dump uses survives, implemented over the enum, and a new
test round-trips every variant through fromHid.
Callers now name the device instead of quoting its id:
- ps2-library's DeviceType.hid() and ps2-bus's descriptor lookups use
HardwareId.ps2_keyboard / .ps2_mouse.
- device-manager's driverFor parses the HID once with fromHid and
switches on named values.
- acpi.zig's isPciRootNode carried the same ids twice, as strings and
as packed-EISA integers (0x030AD041/0x080AD041); both branches now
decode to the string form and answer through one isPciRootHid helper
using .pci_bus / .pci_express_root_bridge.
- build.zig threads the acpi-ids module (previously kernel-only) into
every user binary, like xkeyboard-config.
The flat analog of pci-class for acpi_device nodes. ACPI has no class/subclass/prog-IF
taxonomy — a device's identity is its _HID string itself (PNP0303 *is* "PS/2
keyboard") — so this is a plain id -> name registry, not a hierarchical decoder.
New system/devices/acpi-ids.zig (module `acpi-ids`): the common standard PnP/ACPI
hardware IDs; vendor-specific ids (QEMU0002, etc.) have no registry name and print the
raw HID. Shared reference data like pci-class. The dump now names each _HID:
KBD_ [acpi_device] hid=PNP0303 (PS/2 Keyboard)
COM1 [acpi_device] hid=PNP0501 (16550A-compatible Serial Port)
RTC_ [acpi_device] hid=PNP0B00 (Real-Time Clock (RTC))
LNKA [acpi_device] hid=PNP0C0F (PCI Interrupt Link Device)
FWCF [acpi_device] hid=QEMU0002 (vendor-specific: raw HID)
Host test covers known ids and the unknown/empty fallthrough. Suite 41/41 plus host
tests.
`pci_device` alone says nothing — an ISA bridge, an AHCI controller, and an xHCI USB
controller are all just `pci_device` by DeviceClass. The identity lives in the 24-bit
class code (base class / subclass / prog-IF) that discovery already recorded in
ids.pci_class but the dump threw away.
New system/devices/pci-class.zig (module `pci-class`): pure reference data from the PCI
spec (per the OSDev PCI table) decoding the triple into names — className, subclassName,
progIfName, plus ClassCode.unpack. No hardware access, so it's shared by kernel
discovery and any future user-space PCI tool. device_tree.dump now prints, under each
PCI function, its class/subclass/prog-IF as both hex and name:
pci0:00:1f.0 [pci_device]
class 0x06 (Bridge) subclass 0x01 (ISA Bridge) progif 0x00
pci0:00:1f.2 [pci_device]
class 0x01 (Mass Storage Controller) subclass 0x06 (Serial ATA Controller) progif 0x01 (AHCI 1.0)
Host test covers the decoder (bridge/AHCI/xHCI, the "Other" 0x80 convention, unknowns).
Suite 41/41 plus host tests.
Detect the IOMMU: discovery now parses the ACPI DMAR table, finds the first VT-d
DMA-remapping unit (DRHD), maps its register block, and records its version and
capabilities (iommu_present/base/version/capabilities in the platform info). On QEMU's
emulated intel-iommu this reads back a real unit (base 0xfed90000, version 1.0).
This is detection only, and deliberately so. A full VT-d bring-up — per-device
translation domains that confine a driver's DMA to the buffers it dma_alloc'd — is the
real device-side safety guarantee, but it cannot be verified without a DMA-capable
device driver (none exist yet) and QEMU's intel-iommu to fault against. Writing that
enforcement now would be a large body of unverifiable page-table code; it belongs with
the first DMA driver, which is both the natural order and the only way to test it. Until
then the caveat stands in full: device_claim on a DMA-capable device is still equivalent
to granting ring 0. The docs say so plainly.
New `iommu` test (harness boots it with -device intel-iommu via a new per-case qemu_extra
hook) confirms the DMAR is parsed and the unit's registers read. Suite 40/40 plus host
tests.
Two parts, both blockers for real PCI drivers.
ECAM config space per function: enumeratePci now gives every pci_device its own 4 KiB
configuration window as resource 0. A claimed PCI driver mmio_maps that to reach its
command register, BARs, and — the point — its capability list (MSI/MSI-X, PCIe extended
caps), with no new syscall. Verified in the discovery test (QEMU q35's functions each
carry it).
MSI: msi_bind(device_id, endpoint) -> address (rax), data (rdx) allocates a per-device
edge-triggered vector, binds it to the endpoint, and returns the (address, data) the
driver programs into its own MSI capability. Unlike irq_bind there's no GSI, no I/O APIC
entry, no sharing, and no ack cycle — dispatch recognises an MSI vector (vector_gsi ==
none, msi_bound set), EOIs, and notifies. Owner-keyed release drops the binding on exit.
Legacy INTx (_PRT parsing + shared lines) is deliberately skipped; MSI is the real
answer.
QEMU's HPET has no MSI, so the new `msi` test proves the vector-routing path with a
self-IPI (new apic.selfIpi) standing in for the device's MSI write: bind a vector,
fire it, the bound endpoint is notified. The msi_bind syscall wraps irq.msiBind with
the claim check and lands its first real use with the first PCI driver. Suite 39/39
plus host tests.
The `system` module (formerly `danos`) had become a grab-bag: it held the
loader<->kernel handoff *and* the kernel<->user ABI *and* the device wire types, in
one module three different audiences imported. Usage proved the seam — the
bootloader never touched the syscall/device ABI, and user space never touched the
boot handoff — so split it by audience, one module per contract:
system/boot-handoff.zig loader <-> kernel: BootInformation, Framebuffer,
MemoryMap, the VM layout + physicalToVirtual, kernel_abi
system/abi.zig kernel <-> user, core: SystemCall, mmap prot flags,
page_size, notify_badge_bit, ServiceId
system/devices/device-abi.zig kernel <-> user, devices: DeviceDescriptor,
DeviceClass, ResourceDescriptor, ResourceKind, ...
device-abi is the devices sub-project's public interface, exposed as its own module
the way vfs exposes vfs-protocol — importable by user space, unlike the
kernel-internal device model it also feeds. That collapses a real duplication:
DeviceClass and ResourceKind were defined twice (device-model.zig and the contract,
kept "in sync by hand"); device-model now re-exports them from device-abi, so the
enum a driver matches on and the one the kernel classifies with are one type.
Each import now declares which contract it speaks: the bootloader imports only
boot-handoff; a driver only abi + device-abi (via the runtime); the kernel all
three. This also retires the `system` / `runtime.system` name overlap. page_size
lands in abi (it's part of the mmap contract user space aligns to); the bootloader
keeps its own local 4 KiB constant so it depends on nothing but the handoff.
All 21 importers rewired, docs updated to keep /system mapping to source. Build,
host tests, and the QEMU suite (36/36) all green.
The shared kernel<->user ABI contract (BootInformation, the SystemCall numbers,
DeviceDescriptor, page_size, ...) is now the `system` module at
system/system.zig, following the convention that a directory's root file takes
the directory's name.
One overlap to note: the runtime's syscall wrappers are already `runtime.system`,
so the single file that uses both the contract and those wrappers
(library/runtime/heap.zig) aliases the wrappers locally as `system_calls`. The
two are distinct (top-level `system` vs `runtime.system`); everywhere else the
contract is just `system`.
Also: the QEMU run's serial capture now lands in the FHS log location,
zig-out/var/log/system/serial0-<timestamp>.log — a stand-in for the kernel's own
logging system, which will eventually write there itself.
Suite 35/35 plus host tests green.
Follow-up to the monorepo re-org. Suite 35/35 plus host tests green.
POSIX compatibility is now its own library, library/posix/ (unistd, stdio),
layered strictly over the runtime — it calls the runtime's IPC/heap, never
system calls directly. The runtime is now POSIX-free (the danos-native
application ABI). The VFS wire protocol is danos-native throughout
(Stat -> FileStatus, .stat -> .status, O_CREAT -> create); the POSIX layer
maps the POSIX spellings at the boundary. The coding standard's ABI-name
exception is scoped to one place: a file is allowed POSIX spellings only if it
lives under library/posix/ — everywhere else, danos naming with no exception.
Naming fixes, all mechanical:
- initrd -> initial-ramdisk: the source file, the module, the tool
(make-initial-ramdisk.py), the artifact (initial-ramdisk.img, including the
bootloader's load path), and the identifiers.
- system/kernel/device-service.zig -> devices-broker.zig: it is ring-0 kernel
code (the trusted device table + claim capability), not a ring-3 service. The
future user-space device *manager* (policy) will live in system/services/.
- Dropped the daemon `d` suffix: hpetd -> hpet, busd -> bus. A driver lives in
system/drivers/, so the folder already says what it is; encoding the role in
the name too is redundant. The coding standard drops that exception.
- system/devices/aml/interp.zig -> interpreter.zig (the type was already
Interpreter).
The source layout now mirrors the runtime filesystem hierarchy
(docs/danos-file-system-hierarchy-FSH.md): what lives under system/ in the
source is what a running danos represents under /system. Each service and
driver is a sub-project directory that is its own Zig module — cross-project
references go by module name, never by a path into another project's files.
Moves (all git mv, history preserved):
- src/ -> system/ (danos internals; the self-representation)
root.zig -> danos.zig (the kernel<->user contract module)
kernel/arch/ -> kernel/architecture/ (arch -> architecture)
device/ -> devices/ (what /system/devices reflects)
boot/ -> /boot (the loaders, top level)
- sbin/ -> split by role:
init, vfs -> system/services/<name>/<name>.zig
hpetd, busd -> system/drivers/<name>/<name>.zig
vfs-test -> system/services/vfs/vfs-test.zig (inside the vfs project)
- lib/ -> library/runtime/ (room for other libraries beside runtime)
The VFS wire protocol becomes its own module, system/services/vfs/protocol.zig
("vfs-protocol"): the vfs sub-project exposes its interface, and the runtime's
file layer imports it by name. First instance of the "protocol module" pattern
(docs/driver-model.md); usb/block will expose theirs the same way.
Also: fix a naming-standard violation in the protocol — Op -> Operation (and
req -> request, _pad -> _padding). Docs updated: /system/services added to the
FHS doc, a repository-layout section added to the docs index, and stale source
paths swept across comments and docs.
Runtime boot paths are unchanged (the bootloader still loads /sbin/init);
aligning the runtime filesystem to the FHS is a separate follow-up. Suite 35/35
plus host tests green.
Daniel Samson